Product Filter

Starting with the most popular item, these products are currently trending on our site.

97 products found in Customer Favorites

Jesus Sweetest Name I Know 12 Candy Canes & 12 Bookmarks Box Set
  • $4.99
Strawberry & Cream Hard Candy Rolls, 9 Count
  • $13.50
Strawberry & Grape Flavored Jesus Lives! Cross Pop, Bookmark & Activity Sheet Set, 12 Count
  • $21.50
Jesus Easter Pastel Colored Candy Corn Promise Seeds, 15 Count
  • $5.99
Sugar Free Fish Shaped Peppermint Flavored Mints in a Pocket Sized Tin, 9 Count
  • $20.50

Sale

Strawberries & Cream Hard Candy 2.5 Pound Bag, 180 Pieces
  • $33.99
  • $19.99
Orange & Cream Hard Candy Rolls, 9 Count
  • $13.50
Orange & Cream Hard Candy 1 Pound Bag, 75 Pieces
  • $9.99

Sold out

Jesus Our Shining Hope Red Ornament Star Tin With Old-Fashioned Soft Peppermint
  • $6.99
Scripture Candy Inspirational Bookmarks
  • $4.00
Valentine's Day Cherry Flavored Pops and Cards Bag, 30 count
  • $7.99
Jesus Our Shining Hope Green & Red Star Tin, 10 Milk Chocolates Pieces
  • $7.99
God & Country Old-Fashioned Red, White & Blue Soft Mint, 50 Pieces
  • $4.99
Old-Fashioned Soft Peppermint Gable Gift Box, 8 Ounces
  • $4.99
God So Loved Me, That He Gave Me You Milk Chocolate Pink Heart Tin, 9 Pieces
  • $7.99
Old-Fashioned Soft Peppermint Christmas Gable Gift Box, 8 Ounces
  • $4.99
Mother's Day Tower Gift Box Set
  • $19.99
Assorted Cream Flavor Hard Candy, 180 Pieces
  • $33.99
Peaches & Cream Hard Candy 5.5oz Bag, 25 Pieces
  • $3.49

Sale

Orange and Cream Hard Candy 2.5 Pound Bag, 180 Pieces
  • $33.99
  • $19.99
The Jelly Bean Prayer Spring Themed Bag, 50 Count
  • $20.99
God So Loved Me, That He Gave Me You Milk Valentine & Wedding Chocolates in a Clear Bag, 24 Count
  • $10.99

Sold out

Vanilla Flavored Scripture Cookies Clear Bag, 10 Count
  • $7.99
Blueberries & Cream Hard Candy 5.5oz Bag, 25 Pieces
  • $3.49